Your Place or Mine watches like an anime series localised for our consumption. To be specific, it's a reverse-harem, where the protagonist seems to be surrounded by good-looking guys all out to woo her affection. I like harem animes, and I have been wondering what it would be like to have the genders reversed. I got my wish and I'm not too sure how well i like it.
But first off, let me get this off my chest: What is the deal with Bret Jackson's colouration? I know it's not a good idea to judge a person by the colour of their skin, but his tanning-bed skin tone is really, really distracting. It doesn't help that his features are quite caucasian, and his eye and hair colour makes him look more brown than is rightly normal. Everybody else looked pretty much okay so either the camera hates him or he really should stay away from the tanning salon.
Ehem. With that out of the way, let us proceed!
You get a controlling mother who seems determined to make her daughter unhappy (Jackie Lou Blanco) by setting her up in an arranged marriage, who, despite a few plot twists still seems to make decisions based on how much grief she'll cause her daughter. Whose idea of motherhood is telling Haley that she cannot teach her how to cook because, asking her daughter rhetorically, "does she look like the type who knows how to cook".
Yaya to the rescue.
After an hour of watching these selfish and self-centered characters run around causing themselves unnecessary grief, I was left so devoid of sympathy that even the arrival of Teddy Bear Jr. Andre Paras as your typical anime childhood friend (with all the plus points that entails) still failed to elicit any sort of the expected sympathetic response from me.
So to cap this off, I'll just write down a few more of my observations:
- Haley likes walking out and/or running so she'll get chased. She walks out on her boyfriend, she walks out of meetings (repeatedly), out of bed, etc. She did this like five or six times
- So much product placement. The movie went through as many food outlets, complete with external shots, as the number of times Haley walked on out people
- Almost every character here is a selfish prick. Family members moreso. With brothers like those, who needs a better set of villains
- What's the deal with that lecturing lawyer or doctor or shrink, extolling the virtues of a pragmatic marriage?
- Haley seem so determined to make herself unhappy!
Ultimately, even by anime standards, the plot is overly contrived, made worse by the fact that the characters elicit so little sympathy, you would've cheered them on in their misery. I think I am not the target audience for the story or the movie, but I did not set out to spend 190 pesos just to hate the thing I'm watching. Try harder please, Viva. And Russell, stop supporting the tanning lotion industry, you could actually act decently and might have a future in the industry and I'll probably have to watch a few more of your movies, just hopefully with a more normal skin tone.
Verdict: 1.5/5 Skip it.
TL;DR:
+ Production values seem to be decent, though outdoor locations seems to all be within Quezon City
+ Bret Jackson shows promise
- Contrived plot
- Poor pacing
- Some gaps within the story (how did Haley and Seth become chums all of a sudden)
---- The characters, ugh!
Details:
Title: Your Place or Mine
Genre: Reverse-harem Teen Drama, Wattpad
Release Date: April 29, 2015
Notable Actors: Andi Eigenmann, Andre Paras, Jackie Lou Blanco